Calvary: Upholding the Dignity of Life at Every Stage

The following statement is from Tony Brennan, the Regional Director of Mission at Calvary St John’s Hospital. In it, Mr. Brennan explains the philosophy underpinning Calvary’s decision to not provide assisted-suicide services in its hospitals.

At the heart of Calvary’s mission is a deep and enduring belief in the inherent dignity of every human life. This dignity does not depend on health, independence or productivity. It is present from the beginning of life to its natural end, and it is never lost through illness, disability, ageing or vulnerability.

Calvary exists to heal where possible, to care always, and to never intentionally cause death. Our understanding of care is grounded in the belief that every life is worthy of compassion, respect and protection, especially when people are at their most fragile.

Importantly, Calvary will never block or interfere with a person’s lawful choice to access VAD elsewhere. Nor do we turn away from people who raise questions about it. When someone in our care expresses interest in VAD, we respond with respect, sensitivity and compassion. We listen. We remain present. We continue to care.

In all that we do, we seek to affirm this truth: every life matters, every person matters, and dignity is never lost.

In Tasmania, the End‑of‑life choices (Voluntary Assisted Dying) Act 2021 sets out a legal framework for Voluntary Assisted Dying (VAD). The act came into effect in October 2022 and includes provisions for an independent review which opens in May and June 2026. While this legislation forms part of the broader health system in which we operate, Calvary’s response is shaped first and foremost by our values.

No one is abandoned at Calvary — especially at the end of life. Our staff are there to have the difficult conversations, to accompany people and families through fear and uncertainty, and to ensure that every person feels heard, valued and cared for until the very end.

Some practices, including voluntary assisted dying, are not consistent with Calvary’s ethic of care. For this reason, Calvary does not participate in any step of the VAD process. This includes making formal requests, assessing eligibility, or administering substances intended to directly cause death. This position is not about judgment or exclusion. It flows from our long‑held commitment to protect life and to care without condition.

We take suffering seriously. People approaching the end of life can experience pain and distress that is physical, emotional, psychological, social and spiritual. Calvary is committed to walking with people through this suffering — not by hastening death, but by relieving pain, addressing distress, offering presence, and providing holistic care that honours the whole person. We also respect a person’s right to refuse treatments that are overly burdensome or no longer helpful.

Tony Brennan

Regional Director of Mission

Calvary St John’s Hospital


Image credit: Calvary St. John’s website.

For information about end-of-life care, please go to our Supports page.

HLPS statement on Calvary hospital takeover

When the Hobart Private Hospital was bought by Catholic provider Calvary Health Care, there was an outcry over future access to some procedures, such as abortions, vasectomies, IVF, gender affirming surgery and assisted suicide.

Several news outlets covered the controversy, including the ABC and the Mercury (behind paywall).

Anne Sherston, President of the Human Life Protection Society, has responded to one such article which appeared in the Mercury; her letter was published in that publication on February 6th.

As President of the Human Life Protection Society in Tasmania, I am writing in response to the article “Access in Jeopardy,” by Judy Augustine, published in The Mercury on December 31, 2025.

Kelly Bruce, CEO of Women’s Health Tasmania, expressed concerns about women’s reproductive health in Tasmania, particularly the reduction of support for surgical terminations. This raises an important question: Why is abortion considered part of “reproductive health,” when the term “reproductive” means
producing new life?

What are people actually fearing? Is it that abortion is not going to be as easily accessible? Why are people so eager to make a human being so disposable?

CEO Kelly Bruce stated, “In practice, public hospitals really only provide surgical terminations up to 14 weeks, though there are some exceptions.”

Babies have been known to be born at 16 weeks. There should be no reason a baby needs to be aborted in a late-term pregnancy; caesarean needs to be the only option in these circumstances.

The fact that Calvary is a Catholic organisation would help uphold the values we should all hold dear. If Calvary is forced into allowing abortions, this would go against religious freedom.

Who are we to say who lives or dies when it comes to an unexpected pregnancy, or, for that matter, for someone who is near death? Not one person has the right to interfere with that. Regarding Voluntary Assisted Dying, there is no evidence that the existing safeguards are sufficient to prevent abuse.

When a woman has had an abortion, not only does the unborn baby die, but the woman’s spirit dies as well. This creates a list of numerous other issues and problems, starting with the mental health of the woman.

Family Planning Tasmania CEO Marcus Di Martino commented that
Pregnancy choices and empowering women to have control of their sexual and reproductive health are really important.” This being so important to women, more education needs to be provided to allow women to be completely informed of the choices they can be provided with, such as keeping the baby or
putting it up for adoption. The baby is innocent and the most vulnerable in this issue, and does not need to be aborted. An unborn baby, in fact, has “No Choice.”

We have enough babies being lost to abortion; we don’t need another facility to join the ranks.